top of page

What Nvidia’s fall tells you about index fund concentration

Writer: TEBI
TEBI
11 minutes ago
6 min read

At 9.30am on Thursday 12 November, Nvidia's shares opened 13 per cent down. The company's founder and chief executive, Jensen Huang, had announced his resignation that morning.


Within half an hour, small investors in the US had poured $111 million into the stock. According to Vanda Research, that was the biggest opening half-hour of retail buying in Nvidia it has ever recorded. Earlier that week, retail investors had also put $42.5 million into funds designed to double Nvidia's daily moves.


Index fund investors, meanwhile, did nothing at all. And for all the warnings about index fund concentration, they had less to worry about than almost anyone.



A third of the value gone


On 6 October, Nvidia's shares closed at a record $239.24. By Wednesday 18 November, they were at $150.96. That's a fall of about 37 per cent, and roughly $2 trillion of value.

The fall came in two stages, and the stock market reacted very differently to each.

The first was a sell-off across AI stocks after the US midterm elections. On 5 November, Nvidia fell 9.3 per cent. The S&P 500 dropped 4.4 per cent, its worst day since April 2025.


The second stage was about Nvidia alone. Huang resigned after reports of extramarital affairs, including one with a businesswoman whom US officials suspect of links to Chinese intelligence. China denies this. On the day his resignation was announced, the S&P 500 fell just 0.35 per cent.


Then came Nvidia's results. They were excellent. Revenue for the latest quarter was $115.8 billion, more than double a year earlier, and it forecast stronger sales for the next quarter than analysts expected. The shares still fell.



The warning about index fund concentration


For the past two years, index investors have been told that an S&P 500 fund is no longer really diversified. It's a bet on a handful of tech giants, the argument goes, with Nvidia the biggest of all.


Not all of these warnings came from scaremongers. In March, Larry Swedroe, one of the most respected names in evidence-based investing, warned that a single bad quarter at Nvidia, Apple or Microsoft could cost index investors more than they think.


Nvidia has now had something much worse than a bad quarter. So this was a real test of what one company's collapse does to an index fund. What happened?



What the chart shows


Michael Batnick at The Compound has plotted every trading day of the last five years. Each blue dot shows how far Nvidia was below its peak that day, and how far SPY, a popular S&P 500 fund, was below its own.


Most of the dots sit along a line. When Nvidia was far below its high, so was the market.

The red dot is Thursday 12 November. Nvidia was 31 per cent below its high. SPY was just 2.3 per cent below. Batnick said nothing like it had happened in recent times.





The gap has narrowed a little since then, but it's still huge. By Wednesday, Nvidia was 37 per cent below its record. The S&P 500 was about 6 per cent below its own.



Why the index held up


An S&P 500 index fund holds companies in proportion to their market value. In August, Nvidia made up about 8 per cent of the S&P 500. That made it the largest company in the index. But more than 90 per cent of the index was something else.



Stat card: Nvidia fell 37 per cent from its record close on 6 October to 18 November, while the S&P 500 fell six per cent


Here's the sum. A 37 per cent fall in a company making up 8 per cent of your fund would knock about 3 per cent off the fund, all else being equal. That's a sizeable loss, but nothing like the damage suffered by someone who held Nvidia alone.


And on the day Huang's resignation was announced, two of Nvidia's rivals rose sharply. AMD gained 5.9 per cent and Broadcom 5.5 per cent. Both are in the S&P 500 too.

Something else happened without anyone lifting a finger. As Nvidia's price fell, its share of the index shrank. On Monday 16 November, it slipped to become the third-largest US company, for the first time in 18 months. No index fund had to sell a single share for that to happen. The fund simply reflects the change.


For UK investors in a global tracker, Nvidia matters less still. At the end of October, it made up 5.25 per cent of the MSCI World index, slightly less than Apple. As a rough illustration, the same 37 per cent fall would take about 2 per cent off a fund like that.



Two experts, two opposite views


On this week's Animal Spirits podcast, Ben Carlson and Michael Batnick, two of the best-known investment writers in the US, couldn't agree about Nvidia's future.


One of them thought Nvidia was 'toast', and that the market was under-reacting. The other pushed back. Nvidia, he argued, is still the dominant company in AI, with long-term contracts and exceptional profit margins.


By the end, they agreed it was impossible to call.


The professionals were just as split. After Huang's resignation, Paul Meeks of Freedom Capital Markets said he was buying Nvidia 'with both hands'. Richard Reyle, chief investment officer at Questar Capital Partners, called it 'uninvestable'.


That's the point. If experienced professionals can't agree whether Nvidia's best days are behind it, what chance do the rest of us have? The good news is that index investors don't need to know.


They did name one winner of the year: the S&P 500 index fund investor. And for people worried that one man's affairs were hurting their retirement savings, one of them had a simple answer: 'Not if you own VTI, you're okay.' VTI is a fund that tracks the whole US stock market.



The giants that fall


History suggests the pessimist's worry isn't far-fetched. Michael Cembalest of J.P. Morgan Asset Management has looked at the ten companies that have been the largest in the S&P 500 since 1960. They include IBM, GE, Exxon and Cisco. Most went on to lose much of their share of the market. Cembalest calls it the Icarus effect.



Quote card: ‘Until very recently, the Icarus effect was in full swing: companies that ascended to be the largest in the S&P 500 eventually returned to earth.’ Michael Cembalest, J.P. Morgan Asset Management


Index investors owned all of those companies, on the way up and on the way down. And they owned whatever replaced them at the top, without having to guess what that would be.



The risk that does matter


None of this means index fund concentration is harmless. But it does show which kind of concentration matters most.


One company collapsing is what an index fund is built to absorb. The bigger risk is when several of the largest companies depend on the same story, in this case AI, and fall together. We saw that on 5 November. We've seen more of it this week. On Wednesday, the S&P 500 fell for a fifth day in a row, its longest losing streak since June, as AI stocks kept sliding.


It has happened before, on a much bigger scale. Look at the far bottom left of Batnick's chart.

Those dots are from 2022, the only time in the past five years that the S&P 500 closed more than 20 per cent below its high. Nvidia was then more than 60 per cent below its own peak. No index fund could have avoided that.



What this means for you


An index fund doesn't protect you from a falling market. If you couldn't live with your portfolio dropping by a quarter, the answer is to hold less in shares. It isn't to pick different shares.


What an index fund does is stop your financial future depending on any one company, however dominant it looks, or on any one person running it. That's the real lesson about index fund concentration. Over the past six weeks, the fund absorbed the company risk, as it should. It didn't absorb the theme risk, and it was never meant to.


The retail investors who bought Nvidia that Thursday morning may yet be proved right. Nobody knows. The point is that you don't have to find out.


If you want to go further on concentration, the TEBI YouTube channel has a playlist that includes a conversation with Ben Felix on exactly this question: How should I build my portfolio?



Sources


Batnick, M. [@michaelbatnick]. (2026, November 12). [Post text from embed code] [Post]. X.

Carlson, B., & Batnick, M. (Hosts). (2026, November 18). [Episode title needed] (No. 491) [Video podcast episode]. In Animal Spirits. The Compound.

Cembalest, M. (2026, November 14). The Icarus files: What's next for Nvidia and AI. Eye on the Market. J.P. Morgan Asset Management.

MSCI. (2026). MSCI World Index (USD) [Fact sheet, data as at 30 October 2026]. MSCI.

Randewich, N., & Mikolajczak, C. (2026, November 12). Retail buyers limit Nvidia stock rout. Reuters.

Swedroe, L. (2026, March 11). The illusion of diversification. Substack.

Vanguard Asset Management. (2026). Why finding tomorrow's winning stocks is harder than it looks. Vanguard Investor UK.



How much to hold in shares


Whether an index fund can absorb the fall of its biggest company is now clear. How much of your money should be in shares in the first place is a personal question, and it's the one this piece leaves open. For readers who want help answering it, TEBI's Find an Adviser directory lists advisers who have publicly committed to evidence-based investing.


For more on what events like this mean for index investors, sign up to the TEBI Digest, TEBI's newsletter of new articles and curated reading.


Stay connected: YouTube | LinkedIn | X



Recently on TEBI




Regis Media Logo

The Evidence-Based Investor is produced by Regis Media, a specialist provider of content marketing for evidence-based advisers.
Contact Regis Media

  • LinkedIn
  • X
  • Instagram
  • Youtube

All content is for informational purposes only. We make no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability or validity of any information on this site and will not be liable for any errors or omissions or any damages arising from its display or use.

Full disclaimer.

© 2026 The Evidence-Based Investor. All rights reserved.

bottom of page